From: Earl SweeneyNotes about how I assembled the AL all-star roster.
I decided to go with 11 pitchers including a left handed and right handed middle inning guy, 2 players at each position, and the 3 best players left over to get to 30 players. I tried to use 200 at-bats as a cut-off point. The back-up catcher is the only player under 200 at-bats. Catcher was a very weak position, and picking the 30th player was very tough.
I have a tendency of favoring players with higher runs created when selecting players.
Odd Facts
Alabama leads the charge with eight all-stars
Jersey gets six all-stars and Beartooth has five
Winnipeg leads their division but only got one all-star
Total of seven teams only have one all-star
The entire central division only had one all-star each
The worst pitching team in the league – Lebanon with a staff ERA of 6.86 has an all-star pitcher
Minnesota was 6th in runs scored but didn’t get an all-star hitter
Windsor has the 5th best ERA and most saves but didn’t get an all-star pitcher
The stolen base leader – Eric Byrnes stays home for the all-star game
The average stat line of the 19 batters is .315 / .385 / .547
The bench actually has a better stat line of .326 / .399 / .550
The staff’s ERA is 2.65 and has a 3 ½ to 1 SO/BB ratio
The only pitcher with a losing record is Lebanon’s Pat Neshek (not surprising)
The only pitcher to allow more than a hit per inning is the wins leader Andy Pettite
Last three players selected
Aaron Rowand – Among league leaders with 61 runs, and 94 runs created.
Scott Downs – there were a few good left handed relievers. Downs’ 1.05 ERA with 8 saves, 2 wins and microscopic 3.85 hits / 9 innings gave him the nod
Howie Kendrick – nice average, but nothing special in other stats. Gets nod as back-up second base since position is weak and Kinsler didn’t play 2nd base
Players who just missed the cut
- Ian Kinsler – A .369 / .468 / .551 line and 2nd in steals is hard to ignore, but only 198 abs, not playing a position and the worst team doesn’t deserve two all-stars hurt Kinsler’s case.
- Matt Stairs – The .686 slug was very appealing but only 175 ABs and only 52 runs created from a slugger.
- Andrew Jones – 20 homers and 59 RBIs are loud but .247 average didn’t warrant a 9th Alabama player.
- Jake Peavy – Would have been the 12th pitcher until I decided to only carry 11. He was also traded to the NL in June
- Mark Teahan –. .344 average – but only 70 runs created is low for an OF
- Brad Hawpe – Arguably the 31st player on a 30 man roster. It was a hard choice between him and Aaron Rowand